Series 1
#1 - Chocolate the Moose
*Rare* - 2 BLUE Chocolate Original 9 Ty Trading Cards
with Sequential Numbers 3388/3510 and 3389/3510!


TWO beautiful ORIGINAL NINE Cards - Blue Chocolate the Moose (#1). Each of these cards is imprinted on the front with 3388/3510 and 3389/3510. Both are see thru except for the areas where the graphic is. Both cards are in mint condition with no bends, creases or fingerprints. Both were stored in collector card protective sleeves upon discovery.
There are ONLY 3,510 Blue Chocolate cards in the world! This set could be a great addition to your collection. Get it today!
The odds of finding ONE Blue Chocolate card are 1 in every 3,450 packs (12,109,032 total packs / 3,510 Blue Chocolate cards). At $2.00 a pack, that's $7,900.00! What are the odds of finding TWO with sequential numbers? This set is a must for the serious collector. Don't miss this one!
| $158.00 for both cards |
Series 1
Original Cards #1-9
The Original 9 cards are printed on a clear acetate (plastic like) material with a number imprinted on them. Each Original 9 cards comes in four different foil colors: red, blue, silver, and gold.Want an Original 9 card? Click below to get more information!
| 1 | Chocolate the Moose | 4 | Legs the Frog | 7 | Splash the Whale |
| 2 | Cubbie the Brown Bear | 5 | Patti the Maroon Platypus | 8 | Spot the Dog |
| 3 | Flash the Dolphin | 6 | Pinchers the Lobster | 9 | Squealer the Pig |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
1. This is the official logo for the Official Beanie Babies® Collector's Cards.
2. The total number of cards produced in this foil color for this Original 9 card.
3. The production number for this card. This is card number 2,037 out of 2,160.
4. This represents the beanie's style number.
5. This is the foil color of the card. The words "Original 9" can be either printed in Red, Blue, Silver or Gold foil. Red is the most common and Gold is the rarest.
6. This is the beanie name and animal type.
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
7. Next to the poem is the card number. This card is number 8.
8. This area displays information about the featured beanie such as birthday, date issued, and retired date.
Although the background of the Original 9 card appears white here, it is actually clear.
There are a few Original 9 cards without a number. According to Cyrk, the makers of the cards, these are production errors. Original 9 cards without numbers are extremely rare and are believed to be worth more than an Original 9 card with a number. Most of the unnumbered cards have a blue foil, but some collectors have reported spotting a few unnumbered red foil cards as well.
All Original 9 cards are limited in production and are very hard to find.
![]()
Formula:
Total Packs / Total Original 9 cards
12,109,032 packs / 103,200 Original 9 cards
Your odds of finding an Original card are 1 in every 117 packs.
Formula:
Total Packs / Total RED Original 9 cards
12,109,032 packs / 68,000 RED Original 9 cards
Your odds of finding a RED Original card are 1 in every 178 packs. At $2.00 a pack, that's $356.00!
Formula:
Total Packs / Total BLUE Original 9 cards
12,109,032 packs / 27,000 BLUE Original 9 cards
Your odds of finding a BLUE Original card are 1 in every 448 packs. At $2.00 a pack, that's $896.00!
Formula:
Total Packs / Total SILVER Original 9 cards
12,109,032 packs / 6,800 SILVER Original cards
Your odds of finding a SILVER Original card are 1 in every 1,781 packs. At $2.00 a pack, that's $3,562.00!
Formula:
Total Packs / Total GOLD Original 9 cards
12,109,032 packs / 1,400 GOLD Original cards
Your odds of finding a GOLD Original card are 1 in every 8,649 packs. At $2.00 a pack, that's $17,298.00!

![]() |
Note: It is important to handle these cards with care. If you are fortunate enough to find one of these cards, be sure to place it immediately into a protective sleeve and then put it inside a toploader. Don't touch the card because fingerprints can damage it. | ![]() |
(Click below for prices and photos)
Series I - Retired 12/98
| # | Card Name |
| 1 | Chocolate the Moose |
| 2 | Cubbie the Brown Bear |
| 3 | Flash the Dolphin |
| 4 | Legs the Frog |
| 5 | Patti the Maroon Platypus |
| 6 | Pinchers the Lobster |
| 7 | Splash the Whale |
| 8 | Spot the Dog |
| 9 | Squealer the Pig |







